Back to stories
The Best Travel: Hard Shell vs. Soft Shell Luggage
Caleb Grant | July 29, 2025

The Best Travel: Hard Shell vs. Soft Shell Luggage

Traveling is a lot of fun. Unfortunately, it can also be a total drag when you have to lug around your luggage. There are two main types of luggage: hard-shell and soft-shell.

The difference between the two is important. Soft-shell luggage is made of a flexible material, such as nylon, and it folds up to save space. Hard-shell luggage is made from plastic, metal/aluminum, or both, and it's just as sturdy as it sounds.

 

What is hard-shell luggage?

Hard-shell luggage is durable and made from hard materials. While soft-shell luggage is definitely easier to store, it's much more prone to damage if it gets dropped.

Are both types of luggage great? Probably not. Soft-shell luggage is smaller and lighter than hard-shell luggage, but it's not as durable as the former.

If you're traveling for less than a week, you should go in a hard-shell suitcase. On the other hand, if you're on a lengthy vacation or simply looking to save money, you should buy soft-shell luggage.

Our recommendation is to always go with the hard-side aluminum checked bags and carry-ons. Think of it as an investment. They might be a little bit more, but you won't have to replace them as often.

 

What is soft-shell luggage?

It's basically just luggage that's just a little softer and folds up. Think of it like a soft cloth backpack or duffel bag that's only folded down. These bags fold down a little differently, so they're not as compact as hard-shell luggage.

There are some features to consider when you're buying your next luggage set, such as: Should you go hard-shell or soft-shell? Does it come with a carry-on bag? Do you want it to be durable or just comfortable? If you're considering buying a soft-shell bag, just keep in mind that the wear and tear on them are always faster than hard side luggage, and they absorb water.

 

How to choose the right luggage

The main feature to look for when buying luggage is weight, warranties, space, and user functionality.

Weight- this really only matters if you have large, checked luggage and you need to save some weight and not go over 50 lbs.

Well, now there is a personal choice in a piece of luggage. Do you need exterior pockets because? If you do, you'll have to go with soft-sided luggage? Most hard-side luggage doesn't have a pocket on the outside.

The Aluminum luggage that opens vertically replaces the outside pockets as it makes it easy to get into your case.

Size of the luggage for overhead bins. Most hard side luggage can is adjusted, but we still recommend the hard side here. Only because you can overpack your soft side luggage. Then when the airline says sorry, that isn't considered a carry-on, you out of luck.

 

Pros and cons of hard-shell vs. soft-shell

Hard-shell luggage Pros:

  • Metal construction (Aluminum or Metal Canvas)
  • Phenomenal durability
  • Very lightweight and easy to carry
  • Always the right size for carrying on
  • Easy to clean
  • Very stylish

 

Cons:

  • Tends to be more expensive
  • Can't over pack

 

Soft-shell luggage Pros:

  • Plastic construction (lightweight)
  • Sturdy but lightweight and flexible
  • It folds down flat and is easy to transport
  • Cheaper

 

Cons of soft luggage:

  • Not very durable and won't withstand years of wear not as durable as hard-shell luggage.
  • Zippers tend to be easy to break in to

 

The biggest pros to hard-shell luggage are that they are incredibly durable and pack flat, so they are easy to carry. Soft-shell luggage can't stand up to the pressure of your legs pressing down on it, which is a major drawback. Choosing the right type of luggage is also an important choice.

Should you go with a hard shell, which can withstand higher temperatures and harsher climates, or should you go with a softer, slightly more breathable material, such as soft-shell, which is easier to transport? The only way to find out is to do your research and see which material is better suited to your travel style.

 

Conclusion

Don't worry; we're not about to pick sides in this debate. The right luggage for you depends on how often you'll need to use it. Pick your luggage based on your style. We highly recommend ALEON and have found them to be the best company to go with.